By Mark Langton
Recently I, on behalf of CORBA, sent an email to State Parks District Superintendent Al Pepito regarding an email he sent us. It included a forwarded email from Maintenance Supervisor Dennis Dolinar explaning why they were now closing trails that have for many years been used with knowledge of both the rangers and the maintenance department. (Note: Ranger and maintenance staffs often work independently, and maintenance can and does make decisions without ranger and/or public input.)
Below are the questions I posed and the answers we received from Al Pepito.
CORBA: What is the timetable of the review period Dennis [Dolinar] references in the end of the second paragraph? (From Dennis Dolinar’s email: “It is our intention to keep this area closed to all users until such time as a complete evaluation of the park’s resources can be completed. There will be no attempt to actually remove the trails themselves unless that internal review warrants it.”]
AP: The review process can take anywhere from a year to 18 months.
CORBA: We find it odd that at this point in time CDPR is expending resources for efforts to close prescriptive trails that clearly are not damaging the resources significantly, if at all. Unless there are native resources that are being impacted, there is no clear reasoning behind closing the trails. I understand that it may be a liability concern, but even then, why weren’t these trails closed years ago?
AP: This is a non-system trail not recognized by in our facility inventory. Thus it has never been through the CEQA review process or permitting process. Just because it exists and there is use, does not give the trail status as a recognized facility. It is a resource maintenance issue that needs to be addressed through restoration practices.
CORBA: We are also concerned that your volunteer partners (MBU, CORBA Trail Work Crew) are not being given ample notice in order that they might be able to inform both their own members and the public which they represent.
AP: Without a Trails Supervisor everyone involved are not being communicated with properly. I have asked that the core staff of the district sit down at our next meeting to discuss this issue. The position has been advertised and hope to have one in place by the end of July or sooner.
Obviously Ranger Pepito’s answers raise other questions, such as whether or not they intend to perform a CEQA (California Environmental Quality Act) assessment. And of course, if the review process takes from a year to 18 months, wouldn’t that mean the trails will be reclaimed by whatever plant life exists–assuming no one uses the trails? CORBA will continue its involvement with this situation.
This “natural reclamation” happened years ago with the original 2 Foxes Trail when the CPS invoked the single track bicycle ban. With no bikes to thrash the plants back, and rolling tires to pack down the trail tread, the trail quickly was returned to nature(about 18 months). I believe this is the end goal of the CPS using the “California Environmental Quality Act” as the vehicle. It took volunteers about 3 years, after the reversal of the bike ban, to re-cut and reopen 2 Foxes Trail.
The “Nanny State” is on the move…..and OH BOY it is ugly!